Skip to main content

Table 4 Diagnostic Accuracy of cardiac ultrasound—Subgroup Analyses

From: The diagnostic accuracy of cardiac ultrasound for acute myocardial ischemia in the emergency department: a systematic review and meta-analysis

 

Number of studies (Participants)

Number of patients with Myocardial Ischemia (%)

Summary sensitivity % (95% confidence interval)

P value

Summary specificity % (95% confidence interval)

P value

Patient spectrum

 Excludes HD

13 (1880)

820 (43.6)

74.1 (58.0 to 85.5)

0.168

91.0 (84.1 to 95.1)

0.029

 Includes HD

13 (2985)

1432 (48.0)

85.8 (73.5 to 93.0)

 

78.0 (66.1 to 86.6)

 

Ultrasound Operator

 Cardiology

6 (727)

276 (38.0)

90.2 (73.7 to 96.8)

0.720

88.1 (71.8 to 95.5)

0.983

 Emergency medicine

6 (1790)

1136 (63.5)

83.1 (60.2 to 94.1)

 

89.2 (73.4 to 96.1)

 

 Sonographer

3 (735)

500 (68.0)

83.7 (55.8 to 95.4)

 

87.6 (59.5 to 97.1)

 

Timing of Ultrasound

 At admission

9 (2700)

1797 (66.6)

89.5 (78.9 to 95.1)

0.038

81.5 (66.2 to 90.8)

0.389

 First 24 h

4 (1025)

229 (22.3)

62.8 (34.6 to 84.3)

 

89.5 (71.4 to 96.7)

 

Type of Ultrasound Device

 Echocardiography device

20 (4413)

2248 (50.9)

81.1 (70.7 to 88.5)

0.809

87.1 (77.8 to 92.9)

0.945

 Cart/Tray-based or Handheld

4 (242)

39 (16.1)

84.0 (53.2 to 96.0)

 

86.5 (58.1 to 96.7)

 

Type of Cardiac Ultrasound Protocol

 TTE

23 (3193)

1186 (37.1)

79.1 (67.5 to 87.3)

0.827

88.3 (79.9 to 93.4)

0.681

 POCUS

5 (1824)

1140 (62.5)

76.4 (47.9 to 91.9)

 

84.7 (59.5 to 95.4)

 

Reference Standard

 Cardiac enzymes only

3 (340)

54 (15.9)

93.8 (73.9 to 98.8)

0.082

50.7 (23.8 to 77.3)

0.014

 Chart review

11 (2968)

1451 (48.9)

65.8 (47.9 to 80.1)

 

93.0 (86.7 to 96.4)

 

 Combination of tests

7 (609)

186 (30.5)

74.2 (52.3 to 88.3)

 

85.2 (70.6 to 93.2)

 

 Coronary angiography

7 ( 948)

632 (66.7)

87.0 (73.2 to 94.3)

 

88.7 (76.2 to 95)

 

Target Condition

 Myocardial infarction

8 (2138)

1159 (54.2)

90.7 (78.3 to 96.3)

0.035

67.4 (49.4 to 81.4)

0.002

 Acute coronary syndrome

16 (2433)

897 (36.9)

68.0 (53.3 to 79.8)

 

93.2 (88.2 to 96.2)

 

Significant coronary stenosis

5 (472)

274 (58.1)

85.0 (65.4 to 94.4)

 

82.7 (81.5 to 91.2)

 
  1. TTE Transthoracic Echocardiography, POCUS point-of-care ultrasonography, HD Heart Disease