Skip to main content

Table 1 Estimated sensitivity and specificity of individual key indicator symptoms reported in EMS calls, compared to call handlers’ performance

From: Predictors of recognition of out of hospital cardiac arrest by emergency medical services call handlers in England: a mixed methods diagnostic accuracy study

 

Sensitivity

(95% CI)

Specificity

(95% CI)

Call handlers’ performance

72.8

(65.8–79.1)

99.4

(99.3–99.6)

Key indicator symptom

 Unconscious

86.0

(80.2–90.5)

93.4

(89.0–96.2)

 Not Breathing

57.9

(50.6–65.0)

97.5

(94.4–99.1)

 Ineffective Breathing

57.3

(50.0–64.5)

60.5

(53.2–67.4)

 Collapse

43.8

(36.6–51.1)

84.4

(78.8–89.2)

 Breathing Yes/Effective

30.3

(23.9–37.6)

16.4

(11.8–22.6)

 Change in Colour

29.2

(22.9–36.0)

81.7

(75.6–86.8)

 Noisy Breathing

25.8

(19.8–32.8)

92.2

(87.4–95.3)

 Died

21.9

(16.2–28.6)

99.3

(96.9–99.9)

 Mouth/Vomit

18.5

(13.4–24.9)

89.4

(84.2–93.2)

 Conscious

16.3

(11.2–22.4)

19.8

(14.3–26.0)

 Eyes open/Staring

15.7

(11.0–21.8)

97.1

(93.9–98.8)

 Cool/Clammy/Cold

15.7

(10.7–21.6)

77.9

(71.3–83.6)

 Reduced or Fluctuating Consciousness

15.2

(10.3–20.9)

79.6

(73.2–84.9)

 Sudden Onset/Deterioration

13.5

(9.0–19.1)

96.1

(92.4–98.3)

 Major Trauma/Haemorrhage

13.5

(8.9–19.2)

95.5

(91.6–97.8)

 Serious/Urgent Problem

10.1

(6.3–15.6)

97.2

(93.9–98.8)

 Cardiac Symptoms/Disease1

7.9

(4.4–12.4)

85.1

(79.5–89.9)

 No Pulse/Output

7.3

(4.0–11.7)

99.4

(97.1–100)

 Bystander resuscitation2

6.7

(3.6–11.0)

100.0

(99.9–100)

 Uncoordinated Movement

6.7

(3.7–11.2)

97.2

(93.7–98.8)

 Seizure-like Activity

6.7

(3.6–11.1)

98.3

(95.4–99.4)

 Unknown or Non-specific Problem

5.1

(2.4–9.1)

92.3

(87.6–95.6)

 Abnormal Pulse/Heart Rate

3.4

(1.2–6.8)

97.8

(94.5–99.4)

 Stroke-like Symptoms

2.8

(1.1–6.2)

96.1

(92.2–98.3)

 Self-harm

2.2

(0.6–5.5)

99.4

(96.8–100)

 Psychiatric Symptoms

1.7

(0.5–4.4)

97.2

(94.0–98.9)

 Death Imminent

0.6

(0.0–2.7)

99.5

(97.0–100)

 Drug/Alcohol use

0.6

(0.0–2.8)

93.9

(89.6–96.8)

  1. 1e.g. chest pain, medical history, 2Including Airway Management /Defibrillation use